How young is too young to join Facebook?
Word recently leaked that Facebook is working on technology that would allow children under the age of 13 years old to use the social-networking site with parental supervision. For example, the child’s account would be connected to the parents and/or the parents would control who the child friends and what apps are being used.
Kids lie about their age
Right now the site doesn’t allow anyone under the age of 13 to open an account. But we all know there are plenty of kids who are on Facebook and have lied about their age to open an account. Some may have done with with their parents blessing and others without. Consumer Reports found that “of the 20 million minors who actively use Facebook,” 7.5 million were younger than 13 and more than five million were younger than 10.
Privacy Laws-COPPA
According to the Huffington Post:
Legally, it has always been possible for Facebook to allow children under 13, but to do so it would have to comply with provisions of the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA) that requires commercial sites to “obtain verifiable parental consent for the collection, use, or disclosure of personal information from children.” But complying with COPPA is difficult and expensive.
Children’s privacy issues have been a hot topic recently. It’s concerning that kids are able to share everything and anything on Facebook (as are adults) and once they click that button it’s out there forever. Once a photo is on the web it’s permanent. Even if you delete it, it’s still there. There’s no room for regret.
I’m quoted in the Los Angeles Times
I was contacted yesterday by the Los Angeles Times to share my opinion about this bold move by Facebook. Click HERE to see what I had to say.
I use Facebook
I use Facebook and I use it a lot- mainly for Groovy Green Livin, but for personal use as well. Most of us on Facebook have seen it all. Photos that make you squirm while thinking “did she really post that?”. Facebook seems to enable us to do things that we might not otherwise do. Sometimes that OK, but in the case of a child who possibly can’t make good decisions that’s a pretty scary prospect.
Facebook is a right of passage
I read a great piece by Gwenn Schurgin O’Keefe, MD in the Huffington Post. She really nailed it:
If we allow our kids to drive without the necessary steps met before they get their license, mistakes will occur and accidents will happen. The same is true for social media sites like Facebook. It’s when we give them those keys to Facebook too young, without social media driver’s ed, that harm occurs — their privacy is compromised, a permanent digital footprint made, cyber-bullying takes place or inappropriate content posted.
What can we do as parents?
James Steyer, author of Talking Back to Facebook was recently interviewed on NPR. Steyer runs Common Sense Media, an organization that helps parents decide which kinds of technology are age-appropriate for their kids. In his interview he suggests this tip for parents:
- Parents should act as a role model for their children. Are you on your phone constantly? Do you Tweet, Facebook, email at your child’s sporting events? I sometimes fail at this miserably, but I completely agree with his point.
I would also add:
- Talk with your children about the dangers of social media. Let them know you are there for them.
- Have your computers in a visible location so you can easily see what they are doing.
What do you think about Facebook’s attempt to open the doors to children under 13?
[Photo used under Creative Commons from Thos Ballantyne/Flickr]
I may be an extremist on this point. But I think 13 is too young–and it isn’t because of cyber bullying (although that’s disturbing, too.) My objection is that it’s far too easy to learn to suck down the stream of “news” that comes at a child on the web, instead of learning to ask the greater questions of “who wrote this?” and “what is the source?”
In short, I don’t want my kids to live in a shallow, wiki-world until they are already great consumers of long-form books.
I’m willing to put my money where my mouth is. I’m shutting down Facebook and (largely) Twitter for the summer.
Great point Sarah. As an adult there are times I forget to ask those same questions. I’m guessing it wouldn’t even cross a child’s mind. Are you really shutting down Facebook and Twitter over the summer? I’m very impressed.
I don’t have children that age yet, but I still think 13 is too young. I believe they will need us to navigate the tricky waters of online social lives and it may be a rite of passage, but I still think it may be too young. This parenting gig is hard. 😉
I think FB should only be for 18 or over. There are just way to many dangers with online predators and such.
I’m going to do it. Lately social media has been wearing me down a bit, even w/o the procrastination effect.
I may have to open Twitter occasionally to tweet blog posts, because over at Blurb is a Verb there are many contributing writers. And it’s not fair if I don’t tweet work that others contribute… I’m still working out the details.
Hi Brenna, I completely agree with you. This parenting gig is so hard! I can barely navigate the social media waters and I do it for a living!
Hey Tiffany! I’m wondering if 18 might be too old? Although rumor has it Facebook is for ‘older’ people.
You’ll have to let me know Sarah. There’s a big piece of me that is envious. Life would be very different for me without social media. I need it also to share my posts-but the time suck is too much.
My son just turned 11 and has, thankfully, no desire to get on Facebook. I do think 13 is too young, maybe 16. It’s hard for me with my business and blog I’m on FB, Twitter and Pinterest for those as well as personal, though I try to keep personal to a minimum. My kids see it and have called me out. They do understand much of my work is on-line though, lol.
T
I don’t have a family yet, but I have young nieces who do have FB. They lied about their age saying that they’re 18 years old. What is more alarming now is that there are explicit videos circulating on that social network. Facebook must do something to stop it because there are SO MANY kids that uses Facebook for fun.
Hi Kathryn, I think there are many children who aren’t honest about their age on Facebook. It’s a big issue since the content isn’t always appropriate.
Hi Tanya, It is hard-I’m on my computer for work all the time so I feel somewhat hypocritical when I tell my kids they aren’t allowed. Using social media sites is a rite of passage and isn’t appropriate for all ages. It just isn’t.